When it comes to music, two abilities often come up in discussions about auditory perception: perfect pitch (also known as absolute pitch) and relative pitch. Both are highly valued by musicians, but they represent different ways of perceiving and interpreting sound. Whether you're a parent of a musically inclined child or an adult learner, understanding the nuances and debunking myths about these skills is essential.
Today, we will break down the science of perfect and relative pitch, explore how these skills manifest in children, teens, and adults, and offer insights on how they can be developed.
Perfect Pitch vs. Relative Pitch: What Is Perfect Pitch?
Perfect pitch, or absolute pitch, is the ability to identify or produce a musical note without any external reference. For instance, a person with perfect pitch can hear a note played on a piano and immediately recognize it as a C or an F#. This skill is often considered rare; estimates suggest that only about 1 in 10,000 people possess perfect pitch (Levitin & Rogers, 2005).
How Perfect Pitch Develops: Research shows that perfect pitch is more likely to develop early in life, particularly before the age of six, suggesting a critical period for its development (Deutsch, 2013). Children exposed to a musical environment from infancy—especially those with early, structured musical training—are more likely to develop perfect pitch. Interestingly, studies show that perfect pitch is more common among speakers of tonal languages like Mandarin, where pitch variation in spoken language is essential to meaning (Deutsch, Henthorn, & Dolson, 2004). This suggests that both genetics and environment play a role in developing this ability.
Perfect Pitch vs. Relative Pitch: What Is Relative Pitch?
Relative pitch refers to the ability to identify the intervals between notes, rather than the individual notes themselves. With relative pitch, a musician can hear two notes and determine their relationship (e.g., one is a perfect fifth above the other). This skill is central to musical activities like transposing, harmonizing, and playing by ear.
Relative pitch is a more widely accessible skill than perfect pitch. Most musicians, even those without formal training, develop some degree of relative pitch. According to Zatorre (2003), relative pitch is a learnable skill, dependent on practice and exposure, and it allows musicians to function within any key or tonality.
Musicians with Perfect Pitch
1. Yuja Wang: The Chinese classical pianist is said to possess perfect pitch, which has helped her excel in the highly demanding world of classical music. Wang’s ability to instantly recognize and reproduce notes aids her in sight-reading complex pieces with remarkable accuracy (Tsioulcas, 2018).
Stevie Wonder: Stevie Wonder is a legendary musician who has perfect pitch. This ability has contributed to his groundbreaking work as a singer, songwriter, and multi-instrumentalist. (McPherson & Gabrielsson, 2002). In 1961, at the age of 11, Stevie Wonder was discovered and signed to Motown's Tamla label.
Charlie Puth:The pop singer-songwriter has frequently discussed his perfect pitch in interviews. Puth has shown off his ability to identify notes from everyday sounds, like the beeping of a microwave or the hum of an air conditioner. He has mentioned that this ability helps him tremendously in both performing and producing music (Variety, 2016).
Musicians Known for Their Strong Relative Pitch:
Paul McCartney: Though McCartney does not have perfect pitch, he has spoken about how his strong relative pitch has served him well throughout his legendary career. McCartney’s ability to harmonize, transpose, and improvise showcases his well-developed sense of relative pitch (Miles, 1997).
John Mayer: The singer-songwriter and guitarist is known for his strong sense of relative pitch. Mayer has talked about how he can hear intervals and chord progressions easily, which helps him compose and play by ear. His ability to connect the notes to the structure of a song, even without perfect pitch, has made him a standout musician (Rolling Stone, 2012).
Eric Clapton: The guitar icon has spoken about his reliance on relative pitch, especially in the context of improvisation and playing the blues. Clapton’s ear for music developed naturally through playing and listening, allowing him to excel as a guitarist without the need for perfect pitch (Clapton, 2007).
Benny Greb, a renowned drummer and educator, about the differences between perfect pitch and relative pitch:
“Perfect pitch is great for identifying individual notes in isolation, but relative pitch is what makes you a musician. It’s what allows you to play with others, to harmonize, and to understand how notes relate to one another in context” (Greb, 2016).
This quote reflects the broader view in the music community that, while perfect pitch can be an asset, relative pitch is often seen as the more critical skill for musical interaction and composition. Many professional musicians rely on their relative pitch abilities to work in various musical environments, from live performances to studio sessions.
Strengths and Weaknesses of Perfect Pitch
Strengths:
People with perfect pitch can identify and name notes instantly, which can be a significant advantage when tuning instruments or sight-reading.
Perfect pitch can help with tasks like transcription, as the musician doesn’t need to find a reference note to identify pitches.
It’s a notable asset for singers, who can match a pitch without needing a starting note.
Weaknesses:
One of the surprising downsides is that those with perfect pitch may struggle when faced with music in different keys or when instruments are slightly out of tune. For example, a piece played on an instrument that’s been tuned down by a half-step can sound "wrong" to a person with perfect pitch, making it harder for them to adjust.
Individuals with perfect pitch may rely less on developing relative pitch skills, which are important for transposing or recognizing intervals between notes.
The ability to identify notes doesn’t necessarily correlate with broader musicality, such as creativity or improvisation.
Strengths and Weaknesses of Relative Pitch
Strengths:
Relative pitch is highly adaptable. Musicians can quickly recognize and work within different keys and tonal structures.
It is especially valuable for playing in ensembles or improvising since it allows the musician to understand how notes fit together in real time.
Relative pitch can be developed at any age, making it a more accessible skill for adult learners.
Weaknesses:
While relative pitch is a crucial tool for musicians, it doesn’t offer the same level of immediate note recognition as perfect pitch. Musicians with strong relative pitch may still need a reference note to identify a pitch or melody.
Developing excellent relative pitch can require consistent, focused practice.
How Perfect Pitch and Relative Pitch Manifest in Children, Teens, and Adults
In Children:
Perfect pitch is most commonly found in children who begin musical training early. The critical period for perfect pitch development suggests that early exposure to structured musical education—particularly in environments that emphasize pitch recognition, such as solfège—may be key to fostering this skill (Takeuchi & Hulse, 1993).
Children who exhibit strong relative pitch may not necessarily have perfect pitch but can still show remarkable musical ability. Learning relative pitch comes naturally as they interact with music, especially in group settings like choir or instrumental ensembles. Games and exercises that focus on interval recognition can help young children strengthen this skill.
In Teens:
As children grow into teens, the window for developing perfect pitch narrows, but teens can still improve their pitch recognition skills through diligent training. By adolescence, most musicians are honing their relative pitch through more complex musical activities, such as learning harmonic theory or improvisation.
For teens, focusing on relative pitch development is essential, as this skill becomes increasingly critical for ensemble work, songwriting, and advanced musical studies. Teens who learn to tune their instruments by ear or practice identifying intervals can develop strong relative pitch that serves them well in both performance and composition.
In Adults:
While the opportunity to develop perfect pitch may diminish with age, adults can still refine their ability to recognize and name pitches. However, it is far more common for adult musicians to focus on enhancing their relative pitch. The adaptability of relative pitch makes it particularly useful for adult learners, who may be returning to music after a hiatus or learning an instrument for the first time.
Adults who practice interval training, chord recognition, and ear-training exercises can improve their relative pitch significantly, often to a level where they can transcribe music or play by ear with confidence. Research shows that musical training and active listening can lead to neuroplastic changes in the brain at any age (Herholz & Zatorre, 2012), meaning it’s never too late to improve relative pitch abilities.
Can Perfect Pitch Be Developed Later in Life?
While there is evidence that perfect pitch is more likely to develop in childhood, recent studies suggest that it may still be possible to train perfect pitch in adulthood, though the results are mixed. In a study by Bermudez and Zatorre (2009), adult participants underwent pitch training and showed improvements in pitch identification, although their performance did not reach the level of those with true absolute pitch.
This suggests that while true perfect pitch may be difficult to acquire later in life, focused training can still enhance pitch recognition skills in adults. Apps, ear-training software, and private lessons can help foster greater awareness of pitch relationships, even if perfect pitch itself is not fully attainable.
Developing Relative Pitch at Any Age
Unlike perfect pitch, relative pitch can be developed at any stage of life. Whether you're a child, teen, or adult, consistent practice is key. Some effective ways to improve relative pitch include:
Interval training: Practicing the recognition of intervals between notes helps to internalize pitch relationships.
Singing exercises: Solfège or scale-singing helps train the ear to identify pitches relative to a tonic note.
Playing by ear: Trying to figure out simple melodies or chord progressions by ear can strengthen both pitch recognition and overall musicality.
Conclusion and Personal Thoughts
Perfect pitch and relative pitch are both valuable musical skills, but they serve different purposes and can develop at different times in life. While perfect pitch is rare and often emerges in early childhood, relative pitch can be developed by musicians of all ages with practice and dedication. Both skills contribute to musicality in unique ways, and understanding their differences can help musicians, parents, and educators foster well-rounded musical abilities in learners of all ages.
Overall, the takeaway from studying this subject, is that it's really never too late to learn relative pitch.
If you are interested in further study about the differences between perfect pitch and relative pitch, I will attach a couple of my favorite video essays below! Feel free to ready further about the subject in the references listed below as well.
Want to strengthen your perfect pitch, or develop your relative pitch? Consider taking music lessons with us at Keen School of Music!
CONTACT INFO
Phone number: 615 682 4939
Email: keenschoolofmusic@gmail.com
BOOK YOUR FIRST LESSON
VIDEO ESSAYS FURTHER DETAILING THE DIFFERENCES BETWEEN PERFECT PITCH AND RELATIVE PITCH.
ADAM NEALY: WHY YOU DON'T WANT PERFECT PITCH
RICK BEATO: PERFECT PITCH VS RELATIVE PITCH
References
Bermudez, P., & Zatorre, R. J. (2009). A distribution of absolute pitch ability as revealed by computerized testing. Music Perception, 27(2), 89-101.
Deutsch, D., Henthorn, T., & Dolson, M. (2004). Absolute pitch, speech, and tone language: Some experiments and a proposed framework. Music Perception, 21(3), 339-356.
Deutsch, D. (2013). Absolute pitch. In D. Deutsch (Ed.), The psychology of music (3rd ed., pp. 141–182). Elsevier Academic Press.
Herholz, S. C., & Zatorre, R. J. (2012). Musical training as a framework for brain plasticity: Behavior, function, and structure. Neuron, 76(3), 486-502.
Levitin, D. J., & Rogers, S. E. (2005). Absolute pitch: Perception, coding, and controversies. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 9(1), 26-33.
Takeuchi, A. H., & Hulse, S. H. (1993). Absolute pitch. Psychological Bulletin, 113(2), 345-361.
Comments